Why passkeys are a step back for personal security: examining account lockout risks, platform lock-in, hardware key limits, and fragile recovery flows.
I really wish that SQRL had taken off, as it solved most of the problems noted. It was effectively passkeys that you generated on the fly based on your private key (which you can back up and restore to other platforms if necessary) and the website domain by scanning a QR code (or clicking rh QR code if your on the same device) and sends the signed challenge to the website to auth you.
No need to login to your manager on random systems, no issues with platform lock-in, no worries about dedicated hardware, no worry about losing your access if your device dies (assuming you backup your shit).
I really wish that SQRL had taken off, as it solved most of the problems noted. It was effectively passkeys that you generated on the fly based on your private key (which you can back up and restore to other platforms if necessary) and the website domain by scanning a QR code (or clicking rh QR code if your on the same device) and sends the signed challenge to the website to auth you.
No need to login to your manager on random systems, no issues with platform lock-in, no worries about dedicated hardware, no worry about losing your access if your device dies (assuming you backup your shit).
Steve put so much time into it too. SQRL really is the superior method of the two.
SQuiRreL!
Yeah, no idea why not popular.
Because it doesn’t encourage vendor lock in to big tech.