As for Kronstadt, soviet power was solidified. The mutineers wanted preferential treatment and an end to Bolshevik soviets, against the will of the majority of workers and peasants. Their demands were suicidal for the Red Army against the Whites, and Stepan Petrichenko fled to join the Whites shortly after.
So you at least kind of acknowledge that it’s not only capitalist propaganda as you usually insist but it includes people who lived there, including socialists, including anarchists (and also left Marxists btw). That’s at least something.
Btw, I love how you refer to “Bolshevik soviets” after I made the distinction between Bolsheviks and soviets but what was I expecting.
Of course individuals have their own opinions on matters that form a massive mosaic of overall views, but the overall support was in favor of the Bolsheviks. The Kronstadt mutiny wanted to make the Bolsheviks impossible to vote for in the Soviets, so they wanted an anti-democratic imposition of their will on the rest of the soviets. Further, just as other factions opposed the Marxists, many anarchists and “left”-Marxists joined the Red Army and supported the Bolsheviks. It wasn’t a binary affair, the rejection of the Bolsheviks by some non-Marxists existed alongside the embrace of the Bolsheviks by many non-Marxists.
In short, the people coalesced around and supported the Bolsheviks, not the mutineers, and what the mutineers wanted would have been disastrous and anti-democratic. The leader of the mutiny, Stepan Petrichenko, joined the White Army after Kronstadt. This isn’t the decisive battle between evil Marxists and good anarchists, it was a battle between the majority of society and a small group of wreckers that quickly overthrew their own leadership and returned to the Red Army.
Most important of all, though, is that this has nothing to do with the initial question: what anarchist critique of Marxism holds up well? Not whenever the two groups may have fought, I mean specific critique of Marxism itself.
These socialist countries aren’t the hellholes the capitalist class portrays them as, and painting the situation as the capitalists being truthful about their enemies yet lying about what socialism is just utterly confuses the mechanics at play.
This was in your first comment and I hope you finally understand that you strawmaned my argument. I never said that they were truthful about their enemies. They obviously pointed out what was bad but so did others including socialists. Neither did I say they were lying about what socialism is. Bolsheviks were socialists. I’m not "True Scotsman"ing or something. But they misrepresented socialism as being synonymous with Bolsheviks and thereby making other branches invisible.
And the critique is in short that Bolsheviks centralized power and took it away from the masses. That’s why I made an example were this happened. That’s what Bakunin and Kropotkin predicted, Goldman and Bergman witnessed and Simone Weil analyzed to name a few. Since you reject this, I won’t bore you with predictions you deny came true.
The Bolsheviks prevented power from being centralized and taken away from the masses by stopping the Kronstadt mutiny. They created a system of worker democracy. I don’t see why you can think the way you do unless you assume the Bolsheviks were just evil.
I’m aware of Bookchin, I used to be an anarchist. Reading historical records and contemporary writings from people living in the Soviet Union proved Bookchin wrong, and his writings inflated due to their utility in the Cold War. I understand your perspective, I just disagree entirely with it and have done a total 180 on what I used to believe, which is in line with what you’re suggesting. I’ve just done too much reading and research for me to agree with it. Not saying you haven’t done your own research, but just linking different opinion pieces isn’t going to overturn my understanding.
I don’t see why you can think the way you do unless you assume the Bolsheviks were just evil.
I’m not trying to convince you of my position and neither should you. My problem is that you try to make other positions look foolish or evil or bigoted or something. I was insisting on different positions, different interpretation of history while you were like “that’s just wrong” and that doesn’t convince anybody as you might have noticed during your time on this platform.
I know people who lived in Bolshevik countries. I know that “double think” is real (what ever you think of the author who coined the phrase) so to say “the approval rates were high”, well, that’s what they said.
My very first comment wasn’t addressed to people like you. I know a comment won’t convince people. It was addressed to people who identity as left but not as Marxists and see no where to go with this. That’s where I was before I looked into anarchism and that’s the kind of people I try to reach and, while not instantly convincing, showing a path they might want to look into at some point.
I think it’s possible for me to both believe that different positions exist, and that they can also stand directly against historical fact. I don’t really see the need to play “nice” with that, for me anarchism was a dead end and Marxism made far more sense, both historically and theoretically, answering many questions anarchism never did.
Anecdote and personal account obviously varies.
As for Kronstadt, soviet power was solidified. The mutineers wanted preferential treatment and an end to Bolshevik soviets, against the will of the majority of workers and peasants. Their demands were suicidal for the Red Army against the Whites, and Stepan Petrichenko fled to join the Whites shortly after.
So you at least kind of acknowledge that it’s not only capitalist propaganda as you usually insist but it includes people who lived there, including socialists, including anarchists (and also left Marxists btw). That’s at least something.
Btw, I love how you refer to “Bolshevik soviets” after I made the distinction between Bolsheviks and soviets but what was I expecting.
Of course individuals have their own opinions on matters that form a massive mosaic of overall views, but the overall support was in favor of the Bolsheviks. The Kronstadt mutiny wanted to make the Bolsheviks impossible to vote for in the Soviets, so they wanted an anti-democratic imposition of their will on the rest of the soviets. Further, just as other factions opposed the Marxists, many anarchists and “left”-Marxists joined the Red Army and supported the Bolsheviks. It wasn’t a binary affair, the rejection of the Bolsheviks by some non-Marxists existed alongside the embrace of the Bolsheviks by many non-Marxists.
In short, the people coalesced around and supported the Bolsheviks, not the mutineers, and what the mutineers wanted would have been disastrous and anti-democratic. The leader of the mutiny, Stepan Petrichenko, joined the White Army after Kronstadt. This isn’t the decisive battle between evil Marxists and good anarchists, it was a battle between the majority of society and a small group of wreckers that quickly overthrew their own leadership and returned to the Red Army.
Most important of all, though, is that this has nothing to do with the initial question: what anarchist critique of Marxism holds up well? Not whenever the two groups may have fought, I mean specific critique of Marxism itself.
This was in your first comment and I hope you finally understand that you strawmaned my argument. I never said that they were truthful about their enemies. They obviously pointed out what was bad but so did others including socialists. Neither did I say they were lying about what socialism is. Bolsheviks were socialists. I’m not "True Scotsman"ing or something. But they misrepresented socialism as being synonymous with Bolsheviks and thereby making other branches invisible.
And the critique is in short that Bolsheviks centralized power and took it away from the masses. That’s why I made an example were this happened. That’s what Bakunin and Kropotkin predicted, Goldman and Bergman witnessed and Simone Weil analyzed to name a few. Since you reject this, I won’t bore you with predictions you deny came true.
The Bolsheviks prevented power from being centralized and taken away from the masses by stopping the Kronstadt mutiny. They created a system of worker democracy. I don’t see why you can think the way you do unless you assume the Bolsheviks were just evil.
If you really try to understand this perspective, maybe take it from a former Stalinist:
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/murray-bookchin-myth-of-the-party
I’m aware of Bookchin, I used to be an anarchist. Reading historical records and contemporary writings from people living in the Soviet Union proved Bookchin wrong, and his writings inflated due to their utility in the Cold War. I understand your perspective, I just disagree entirely with it and have done a total 180 on what I used to believe, which is in line with what you’re suggesting. I’ve just done too much reading and research for me to agree with it. Not saying you haven’t done your own research, but just linking different opinion pieces isn’t going to overturn my understanding.
This reads very different from your last comment:
I’m not trying to convince you of my position and neither should you. My problem is that you try to make other positions look foolish or evil or bigoted or something. I was insisting on different positions, different interpretation of history while you were like “that’s just wrong” and that doesn’t convince anybody as you might have noticed during your time on this platform.
I know people who lived in Bolshevik countries. I know that “double think” is real (what ever you think of the author who coined the phrase) so to say “the approval rates were high”, well, that’s what they said.
My very first comment wasn’t addressed to people like you. I know a comment won’t convince people. It was addressed to people who identity as left but not as Marxists and see no where to go with this. That’s where I was before I looked into anarchism and that’s the kind of people I try to reach and, while not instantly convincing, showing a path they might want to look into at some point.
I think it’s possible for me to both believe that different positions exist, and that they can also stand directly against historical fact. I don’t really see the need to play “nice” with that, for me anarchism was a dead end and Marxism made far more sense, both historically and theoretically, answering many questions anarchism never did.