I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around this. To me, “cheating” is a form of dishonesty. If you are in a relationship that is sexually/romantically nonexclusive, then “cheating” doesn’t exist, since there is a mutual understanding of nonexclusivity. I don’t see how ‘anarchy’ would justify dishonesty within an intimate relationship.
the concept is that under no relationship, any party gets to veto things that don’t affect them.
i can’t tell my partner that she isn’t allowed to stuff with someone else, all the consent that counts is from the people involved in the act.
but more importantly, it acknowledges that some people are stuck in abusive relationships and if they find an ounce of affection outside their hell, then that’s a good thing.
I’m trying to understand. I certainly understand the point of view that intimacy needn’t be exclusive. What I’m not clear is whether that point of view need be shared by both parties in one of these relationships. Let’s leave aside the question of abusive relationships for the moment.
the point is that one person not liking the idea, shouldn’t interfere with the other one’s agency, they are free to disagree, they are not free to impose their rules.
I don’t know if this is just semantics or what, but isn’t that almost every relationship already? Like do whatever you want, but don’t expect the other person to necessarily like it.
point is that a partner demanding sexual and romantic exclusivity is inherently coersive and an unethical demand. therfore ignoring such request is not unethical.
The problem is that in modern society, a chater is often treated as a serious transgression, sometimes leading to social isolation, or even job loss.
That makes RA sound just an excuse, to defend cheating? If someone is demanding exclusivity, you staying in a relationship with them, means agreeing with those rules. By not respecting it, that is cheating - breaking your deal, and their trust - and the other person has the right, to be upset. If you have an understanding beforehand, then it is not cheating, but then that is just an open relationship…? I admit, I do not understand either.
But if you stay with that someone knowing they demand those rules, without intent to obey them, then you are a liar? You have all the right to leave, and then you do not need to follow those BS rules, of course. But being in that relationship means, you are agreeing to follow them. If you think that is controlling, then just do not be in a relationship with that person? Breaking rules and deals does make you a liar, and that is completely immoral, when you are not forced to make those deals, and lie about them in the first place.
The point is that while the rules seem arbitrary to you, that’s just not true for everyone, like it or not. Everyone has different things that they do or don’t enjoy. You say forcing, but it’s more like a conditional. You aren’t entitled to anyone else’s affections under your philosphy, any more than they are entitled to restrict yours under theirs.
I can understand that perspective, but surely people are free to enter into an exclusive relationship with each other, no? Like, if you feel that exclusivity is coersive, and your partner agrees, then there’s no issue. If your partner doesn’t agree, then why are you partners? If they don’t agree, and you pursue sexual relationships externally anyway, then aren’t you just an asshole? Like sure, do as thou wilt, but presumably you care for the feelings of people you are in relationships with.
Lots of people get entrapped in abusive relationships. and it is really hard to leave. then society treats them like shit if they find an ounce of joy and affection somwhere else.
Why would I care about the feelings who wants to control me and call it love, love is the opposite of control.
If this is all just about abusive relationships, then, sure whatever. But if you’re going to call any exclusive relationship abusive by definition, then you will have lost most people.
I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around this. To me, “cheating” is a form of dishonesty. If you are in a relationship that is sexually/romantically nonexclusive, then “cheating” doesn’t exist, since there is a mutual understanding of nonexclusivity. I don’t see how ‘anarchy’ would justify dishonesty within an intimate relationship.
the concept is that under no relationship, any party gets to veto things that don’t affect them.
i can’t tell my partner that she isn’t allowed to stuff with someone else, all the consent that counts is from the people involved in the act.
but more importantly, it acknowledges that some people are stuck in abusive relationships and if they find an ounce of affection outside their hell, then that’s a good thing.
I’m trying to understand. I certainly understand the point of view that intimacy needn’t be exclusive. What I’m not clear is whether that point of view need be shared by both parties in one of these relationships. Let’s leave aside the question of abusive relationships for the moment.
the point is that one person not liking the idea, shouldn’t interfere with the other one’s agency, they are free to disagree, they are not free to impose their rules.
I don’t know if this is just semantics or what, but isn’t that almost every relationship already? Like do whatever you want, but don’t expect the other person to necessarily like it.
point is that a partner demanding sexual and romantic exclusivity is inherently coersive and an unethical demand. therfore ignoring such request is not unethical.
The problem is that in modern society, a chater is often treated as a serious transgression, sometimes leading to social isolation, or even job loss.
That makes RA sound just an excuse, to defend cheating? If someone is demanding exclusivity, you staying in a relationship with them, means agreeing with those rules. By not respecting it, that is cheating - breaking your deal, and their trust - and the other person has the right, to be upset. If you have an understanding beforehand, then it is not cheating, but then that is just an open relationship…? I admit, I do not understand either.
So are you upset that they broke BS arbitrary rules you were forcing on them, or because they had sex?
Because then it is about control, and not love
But if you stay with that someone knowing they demand those rules, without intent to obey them, then you are a liar? You have all the right to leave, and then you do not need to follow those BS rules, of course. But being in that relationship means, you are agreeing to follow them. If you think that is controlling, then just do not be in a relationship with that person? Breaking rules and deals does make you a liar, and that is completely immoral, when you are not forced to make those deals, and lie about them in the first place.
The point is that while the rules seem arbitrary to you, that’s just not true for everyone, like it or not. Everyone has different things that they do or don’t enjoy. You say forcing, but it’s more like a conditional. You aren’t entitled to anyone else’s affections under your philosphy, any more than they are entitled to restrict yours under theirs.
I can understand that perspective, but surely people are free to enter into an exclusive relationship with each other, no? Like, if you feel that exclusivity is coersive, and your partner agrees, then there’s no issue. If your partner doesn’t agree, then why are you partners? If they don’t agree, and you pursue sexual relationships externally anyway, then aren’t you just an asshole? Like sure, do as thou wilt, but presumably you care for the feelings of people you are in relationships with.
Lots of people get entrapped in abusive relationships. and it is really hard to leave. then society treats them like shit if they find an ounce of joy and affection somwhere else.
Why would I care about the feelings who wants to control me and call it love, love is the opposite of control.
If this is all just about abusive relationships, then, sure whatever. But if you’re going to call any exclusive relationship abusive by definition, then you will have lost most people.