Unfortunately, Ruzzia keeps getting that bridge operational within a few days of every attack. The whole thing needs to come down, or Ukraine needs enough ammo to sustain an attack on the reconstruction efforts.
Prior to this attack all the other ones were fairly limited in terms of damage:
In 2022 a truck bomb collapsed a couple spans between concrete piers. Repairing this basically meant casting new concrete sections off-site then moving them into place. It took about 4 months to fully reopen.
The 2023 attack involved sea drones that struck one of the supports. That damaged the road bed but nothing collapsed, and it took only 3 months to fully repair.
The 2025 attack involved underwater explosives, but damage was minimal.
Unlike all those attacks, this one knocked out the main arch that spans the shipping channel. Unlike the rest of the bridge, this 750 foot span is supported from above by the arch so that shipping traffic can sail underneath it.
Repairing this sort of damage is a lot more time consuming & difficult than those earlier attacks. In those previous ones, once you’ve examined the supports and made any repairs to them then you can cast the new concrete bridge segment off-site then use cranes to simply drop it into place onto those supports. But with this arched section you’ll need metalworkers to spend months rebuilding that arch first, then rebuild the suspended road bed under the arch.
It’s going to be extremely difficult for Russia to find metalworkers willing to work under the constant threat of additional drone attacks, not to mention protecting all the materials & equipment that they’ll need at the site of the span. Estimates are that it could take anywhere from 8 months to 2 years to rebuild under optimal conditions. That means not only no new attacks, but favorable weather, unrestricted supplies, etc. And I doubt Ukraine would sit idly by and let that happen.
Must be some super strong bridge (and also heavily protected). I’m wondering if naval drones could damage the pillars so much that it would be unusable. I’m of course not a civil engineer or military expert, so Ukraine is probably doing the best they can.
Unfortunately, Ruzzia keeps getting that bridge operational within a few days of every attack. The whole thing needs to come down, or Ukraine needs enough ammo to sustain an attack on the reconstruction efforts.
As long as it costs them more to keep fixing it than it costs you to keep breaking it continuous harassment is a solid strategy
Prior to this attack all the other ones were fairly limited in terms of damage:
Unlike all those attacks, this one knocked out the main arch that spans the shipping channel. Unlike the rest of the bridge, this 750 foot span is supported from above by the arch so that shipping traffic can sail underneath it.
Repairing this sort of damage is a lot more time consuming & difficult than those earlier attacks. In those previous ones, once you’ve examined the supports and made any repairs to them then you can cast the new concrete bridge segment off-site then use cranes to simply drop it into place onto those supports. But with this arched section you’ll need metalworkers to spend months rebuilding that arch first, then rebuild the suspended road bed under the arch.
It’s going to be extremely difficult for Russia to find metalworkers willing to work under the constant threat of additional drone attacks, not to mention protecting all the materials & equipment that they’ll need at the site of the span. Estimates are that it could take anywhere from 8 months to 2 years to rebuild under optimal conditions. That means not only no new attacks, but favorable weather, unrestricted supplies, etc. And I doubt Ukraine would sit idly by and let that happen.
You make good points except for the labor. I’m sure they’ll find plenty of “volunteers” to work in those conditions.
Would those "volunteers " have any skills or experience constructing bridges?
I’m not sure I’d trust Russias idea of “volunteers” to rebuild a critical bridge. Ukraine could probably knock it down again with just a stern look. 🤣
Within a few days? You are living in a different reality than the rest of us.
Must be some super strong bridge (and also heavily protected). I’m wondering if naval drones could damage the pillars so much that it would be unusable. I’m of course not a civil engineer or military expert, so Ukraine is probably doing the best they can.