• Ulrich@feddit.org
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    3 hours ago

    To me that implies it’s somehow different than just installing software.

    That’s because it is, as I’ve just finished explaining. Again, see the “advanced flow” in OP? This does not apply to “installing software”. It only applies to sideloading. I’m not sure why this is so difficult to understand.

    You could say ‘install from play store’ or ‘install from f-droid’ if you need to specify which app repository you should use

    Did you think about this at all before typing? Which repository do you think the OP refers to?

    From the article:

    None of this says “sideloading” or refers specifically to the term, it refers to the practice.

    Google tries to twist that to mean something only ‘power users’ do and it comes with a ‘educated risk’.

    You’re incredibly naive if you think anyone other than “power users” are sideloading.

    And it does come with risk, because it might come from a reputable source like FDroid or it might be a random app from some unverified (by anyone) sketchy website, and the system has no technological means to tell the difference.

    • IsoKiero@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      3 hours ago

      This does not apply to “installing software”.

      So it doesn’t apply when I click the big button which says ‘Install’ on F-Droid app on my phone?

      And it does come with risk,

      Just like installing software from the ‘secure’ Google Play store.

      Installing software is installing software, no matter where you get that software from. That’s it. You can try to twist that with nuances on terminology or invent new ones, the end result is that an piece of software is installed on the system and nothing more. It doesn’t matter if the software came from play store, f-droid, steam, windows store, shady google drive link or the pirate bay. It doesn’t matter if you’re a power user or never seen a smartphone before in your life.

      Sure, there might differences in potential security, compatibility, licensing and whatever, but it is still a piece of software being installed.

      • Ulrich@feddit.org
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        2 hours ago

        So it doesn’t apply when I click the big button which says ‘Install’ on F-Droid app on my phone?

        Please note the use of quotes. I was using “installing software” the way you were, as in literally any software. Whereas this does not apply to apps in the Google Play Store. That’s why the distinction is important.

        Just like installing software from the ‘secure’ Google Play store.

        Yes, just like that, except a higher level of risk, because potentially no one is verifying the validity of said software. And as I already explained, there’s no technological way for the OS to differentiate a legitimate source like FDroid from a random sketchy website on the internet.

        Installing software is installing software, no matter where you get that software from

        Except it’s not, because sideloading is different, as you know, if you actually read the OP, and if you actually read my comments where I already explained how it’s different.

        Now I’m done repeating myself over and over, so unless you have something new to contribute to the discussion, I’m out. Have a nice day!