• nonentity@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    22
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    23 hours ago

    Financial economics, as an intellectual discipline, is far closer to theology than physics.

    The specious belief that an entity that holds the exclusive legal monopoly over the issuance of the currency its accounts are denominated in, can in any way experience debt in that currency in a problematic manner, unless it explicitly chooses to do so, is the greatest trick the owning class ever pulled to convince their serfs to extinguish their own power.

    • Not_mikey@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      21 hours ago

      It may not be problematic to the government/ entity but it could be problematic for the people using that currency. Sure the government could print $1 trillion, pay off its debt and be solvent, but the people using that currency will most likely experience inflation due to that money printing. In the case of the US that inflation can be blunted by demand for dollars as the global reserve currency, and the fact that its economy is mostly internal, but if you’re a minor nation that relies on imports or exports you’re more likely to end up in a hyperinflationary loop if you try to do MMT.

      Also MMT runs directly up against the bond market. If you start printing money to pay off your bonds, then no one is going to want to buy your bonds, and if no one buys your bonds you’ll be unable to fund the government.

      • AA5B@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 hour ago

        In the case of the US that inflation can be blunted by demand for dollars as the global reserve currency

        This is a risky assumption, as that inflationary spiral is exactly what could knock us off our pedestal. If that ever happened, we’d hit the ground hard. And the current policy chaos is like dancing on the edge, daring anyone to knock us down.

        The US is not in a special place by some inherent quality but mostly by our history as a large and very stable economy. If we’re no longer stable, prudent or mature in our economy, why should anyone trust us?

        A fucking foolish way to lose a huge economic benefit.

      • Stern@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        9 hours ago

        I got my brother a one hundred trillion Zimbabwean bill for his most recent birthday. Gov can definitely print money to solve debt but then one egg will sell for ten grand, which is a whole new much more fun (to read about on wikipedia at 3am, not to live through.) problem.

      • nonentity@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        20 hours ago

        This is a problem when arguing in a realm of make-believe, there’s no intrinsic foundation to draw from or build upon.

        No serious interlocutor is arguing the government, as the currency issuer, should print or otherwise conjure currency to clear ‘debt’. My argument is that what is classified as government ‘debt’ in this context is a misnomer and category error, and would be more accurately defined as the tally of untaxed currency in the market. Fiat currencies are merely scorecards, they represent the current state of play according to the rules the participants are playing by.

        Anyone invoking ‘doing MMT’ is betraying a fundamental misunderstanding of what MMT describes. To my mind, any system which uses a fiat currency yet dismisses MMT is fundamentally flawed, and likely blinded by ideology.

        Like all financial instruments, the ‘bond market’ is entirely imaginary and only possesses power commensurate to the belief it commands. Bonds are only required to ‘fund’ a government if you believe they do. They’re ultimately an inefficient and imprecise tool for doing so, and are better used as a mechanism to temporarily quarantine currency from the economy to suppress spending.

        There’s no intrinsic connection between ‘spending’ by any currency issuing government, and the revenue they accrue via taxation, they’re merely and literally the birth and death of individual currency units. ‘Balancing’ the budget of a currency issuing entity is entirely superfluous, and celebrating surpluses in them is fiscally suicidal ideation.

        • 5318008@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 hour ago

          To my mind, any system which uses a fiat currency yet dismisses MMT is fundamentally flawed, and likely blinded by ideology.

          Then MMT proponents need to start publishing papers. If the mainstream economics journals won’t publish papers on it, there are fringe journals that will happily take those papers.

          I’m completely in favor of developing alternative theories, as long as we’re honest about the strengths and weaknesses of those theories, and willing to subject them to public scrutiny. That includes peer review, and taking the problem seriously when almost all economists reject the basic tenets of the theory. That means developing the theory in a way that addresses problems rather than ignoring them and crying foul when journals won’t publish papers. It’s the same as any other fringe theory: stop complaining about how no one agrees with you, and give us some actual results.

          A person who is not open to that kind of academic review and potential criticism… is blinded by ideology.