Even rehabilitation is exclusion from human rights because you are still taking away the freedom of travel. I don’t think there is an exclusion free way of approaching this topic. You might rehabilitate someone in a closed facility for ten years and it might turn out that they were innocent after all. There really is no universally ideal, error free solution for responding to crime in my opinion. Everyone just draws their own red line of unacceptable. Tate suffering is a small bubble of ideal though.
There are sociopaths who can be very manipulative and quite good at pretending to be very normal. And then there are chronically introvert people from whom you won’t be able to get much of a rearin from. If you set the duration based on personality you are bound to make even more mistakes than one that is based on crime evidence. You can just release a convicted murderer or rapidt in a year because they act completely normal. Yes there can be psychological evaluations by experts that are better at reading people than me or you but not only the efficiency of these people will vary wildly from place to place, there is also no way that it will be more objective than an evidence based system.
When we decide to exclude certain people from human rights protection, we will keep excluding.
Even rehabilitation is exclusion from human rights because you are still taking away the freedom of travel. I don’t think there is an exclusion free way of approaching this topic. You might rehabilitate someone in a closed facility for ten years and it might turn out that they were innocent after all. There really is no universally ideal, error free solution for responding to crime in my opinion. Everyone just draws their own red line of unacceptable. Tate suffering is a small bubble of ideal though.
rehabiliation doesn’t have a fixed timing. Each person is different. If they are innocent, it will probably be clear in the first month or so.
There are sociopaths who can be very manipulative and quite good at pretending to be very normal. And then there are chronically introvert people from whom you won’t be able to get much of a rearin from. If you set the duration based on personality you are bound to make even more mistakes than one that is based on crime evidence. You can just release a convicted murderer or rapidt in a year because they act completely normal. Yes there can be psychological evaluations by experts that are better at reading people than me or you but not only the efficiency of these people will vary wildly from place to place, there is also no way that it will be more objective than an evidence based system.