As reported by 404 Media, writer and musician Samantha Shokin recorded a 50-second version of Bulgarian folk song Bre Petrunko during the pandemic, initially uploading it to...
I remain astounded that the DCMA’s glaring problem with spurious claims hasn’t been addressed by now. At a minimum there should be severe punitive damages mandated for bad faith takedown requests.
No, because what YouTube is doing is just their own thing to police their platform and it rarely gets to the point of actually invoking the DMCA. Like how a business could have their own stricter dress code without needing to invoke indecency laws.
There is a rule for punishing knowingly false claims
But it doesn’t cover false claims via bots because those weren’t done knowingly, and that needs to be fixed
The standard to prove it is also terrible, it should be changed to negligence (any errors that wouldn’t have been made by a competent claimant are punishable). That standard would also punish operators of misconfigured copyright bots
Part of the issue appears to involve the license of the sample. The bot appears to be assuming the artist has full rights to their song, even though it includes samples and the legality of the sample in question is a bit murky.
I should be surprised that YouTube doesn’t have a way to mechanism to handle sampling, but they seem to want as cheap a process as possible.
I remain astounded that the DCMA’s glaring problem with spurious claims hasn’t been addressed by now. At a minimum there should be severe punitive damages mandated for bad faith takedown requests.
It’s not a problem inherent to DMCA, it’s YouTube’s way of handling claims
Isn’t it a bit inherent to the DMCA if there’s no punishment or limitations on spurious claims?
No, because what YouTube is doing is just their own thing to police their platform and it rarely gets to the point of actually invoking the DMCA. Like how a business could have their own stricter dress code without needing to invoke indecency laws.
There is a rule for punishing knowingly false claims
But it doesn’t cover false claims via bots because those weren’t done knowingly, and that needs to be fixed
The standard to prove it is also terrible, it should be changed to negligence (any errors that wouldn’t have been made by a competent claimant are punishable). That standard would also punish operators of misconfigured copyright bots
Part of the issue appears to involve the license of the sample. The bot appears to be assuming the artist has full rights to their song, even though it includes samples and the legality of the sample in question is a bit murky.
I should be surprised that YouTube doesn’t have a way to mechanism to handle sampling, but they seem to want as cheap a process as possible.