As reported by 404 Media, writer and musician Samantha Shokin recorded a 50-second version of Bulgarian folk song Bre Petrunko during the pandemic, initially uploading it to...
The copyright system definitely has some problems, but this isn’t about the actual copyright laws, it’s about YouTube automatically siding with businesses who file false and/or malicious copyright claims even though the content creators are clearly within their rights, and the law. YouTube has zero consequences for anyone fraudulently claiming copyright, but the appeals process for content creators, even when they are clearly in the right, is a bureaucratic nightmare like something out of a Franz Kafka novel, and guidelines they have to follow are constantly changing.
For example, Davie504, who has a popular channel for bass players, recently got a copystrike from Simon and Garfunkel’s record label for playing the sound of silence. Not for playing the Simon and Garfunkel song, The Sound of Silence. For literal silence. No music, the literal absence of sound. And YouTube was like, “Yes, this is a perfectly reasonable copyright claim.”
The copyright system definitely has some problems, but this isn’t about the actual copyright laws, it’s about YouTube automatically siding with businesses who file false and/or malicious copyright claims even though the content creators are clearly within their rights, and the law. YouTube has zero consequences for anyone fraudulently claiming copyright, but the appeals process for content creators, even when they are clearly in the right, is a bureaucratic nightmare like something out of a Franz Kafka novel, and guidelines they have to follow are constantly changing.
For example, Davie504, who has a popular channel for bass players, recently got a copystrike from Simon and Garfunkel’s record label for playing the sound of silence. Not for playing the Simon and Garfunkel song, The Sound of Silence. For literal silence. No music, the literal absence of sound. And YouTube was like, “Yes, this is a perfectly reasonable copyright claim.”