They absolutely did notice, because the legions weren’t sitting around twiddling their thumbs before going away; they were fighting the various barbarians. When the legions left, the barbarians rolled in and that was pretty bad, to put it lightly. Not to make it seem like the Romans were innocent defenders of civilization, but when an invading army rolls into a conquered/raided territory in this period they rape and pillage everything that isn’t nailed down, and of course it’s no fun to have your city sieged or sacked. The loss of trade (since the Roman state wasn’t there to crack down on banditry and piracy) also reduced the complexity and prosperity of the Roman economy, leading to population decline that wouldn’t be made up for centuries. Here’s a good read on the topic by a Roman historian, but the short of it is that it would’ve absolutely sucked to live anywhere in the Roman Empire within a century before or after its fall in the West. Here’s a relevant quote:
Living standards thus declined back down to the pre-Roman Iron Age norm while at the same time the carrying capacity of the empire also declined down to that norm, leading to what must have been decades of brutal misery as food ran short, malnourished infants died before their time, cities shrank and the world grew poor.
I mean what timeframe are you working with here? In any case here’s a good read on what the fall of Rome in the West would’ve actually looked like. Relevant excerpt:
Living standards thus declined back down to the pre-Roman Iron Age norm while at the same time the carrying capacity of the empire also declined down to that norm, leading to what must have been decades of brutal misery as food ran short, malnourished infants died before their time, cities shrank and the world grew poor.
And that’s aside from all the raping and pillaging that happened whenever Rome lost, which was increasingly often leading up to its fall (again in the West).
Again, it’s contentious. The fall of Rome didn’t happen in one lifetime. In another comment I say the fall may have started before Rome became an empire, when the electorate started becoming spoiled.
But yes, around 4-500CE is the generally approved timeframe. But historians still argue back and forth about it - and I’m personally on the side that says the fall took several generations and the sacking of Rome was just the punctuation - or when face met ground.
I mean everybody noticed the fall of Rome since it fell by being conquered by barbarians.
The folks out in the provinces didn’t necessarily notice that. They just noticed the legion garrisons went away and the roads quit being maintained.
They absolutely did notice, because the legions weren’t sitting around twiddling their thumbs before going away; they were fighting the various barbarians. When the legions left, the barbarians rolled in and that was pretty bad, to put it lightly. Not to make it seem like the Romans were innocent defenders of civilization, but when an invading army rolls into a conquered/raided territory in this period they rape and pillage everything that isn’t nailed down, and of course it’s no fun to have your city sieged or sacked. The loss of trade (since the Roman state wasn’t there to crack down on banditry and piracy) also reduced the complexity and prosperity of the Roman economy, leading to population decline that wouldn’t be made up for centuries. Here’s a good read on the topic by a Roman historian, but the short of it is that it would’ve absolutely sucked to live anywhere in the Roman Empire within a century before or after its fall in the West. Here’s a relevant quote:
Before that, actually - though when the fall started is historically contentious, we don’t say you start falling when your face hits the ground.
I mean what timeframe are you working with here? In any case here’s a good read on what the fall of Rome in the West would’ve actually looked like. Relevant excerpt:
And that’s aside from all the raping and pillaging that happened whenever Rome lost, which was increasingly often leading up to its fall (again in the West).
Again, it’s contentious. The fall of Rome didn’t happen in one lifetime. In another comment I say the fall may have started before Rome became an empire, when the electorate started becoming spoiled.
But yes, around 4-500CE is the generally approved timeframe. But historians still argue back and forth about it - and I’m personally on the side that says the fall took several generations and the sacking of Rome was just the punctuation - or when face met ground.