Well he did “promise” to donate 6.6 billion to help with world hunger if the United Nations World Food Program could prove that that amount of money would help.
You’re correct it wouldn’t solve hunger BUT Musk could have easily said “HA! proved you wrong BUT I do want to help people from starving so here is 6.6 billion.” Instead he just fucked right off and did nothing.
The world food guy could have also started with: “Hey Elon, can you spare $X to help with world hunger, it’ll mean the world to millions of people”
Starting by antagonizing someone to drum up hate and false headlines like CNN used isn’t usually the best way to get someone to help. (edit to clarify CNN’s headline was correct, the guy said that, but the content they reposted was false)
It every person but one is perfectly taken care of, and that one is starving, is that insufficiently “solved”?
Is “solved” calories provided, or total guaranteed calories? Active daily value, sedentary, or minimal subsistence? Mean, median value? Is it over all ages, or age calibrated?
Does it include delivery, or just making locally available? What about security for areas that people will steal food for power and control?
Hinging it on “solved” is a way to guarantee you can never be held to it.
The money had to solve it, not help.
Huge difference.
You’re correct it wouldn’t solve hunger BUT Musk could have easily said “HA! proved you wrong BUT I do want to help people from starving so here is 6.6 billion.” Instead he just fucked right off and did nothing.
He could have ya.
The world food guy could have also started with: “Hey Elon, can you spare $X to help with world hunger, it’ll mean the world to millions of people”
Starting by antagonizing someone to drum up hate and false headlines like CNN used isn’t usually the best way to get someone to help. (edit to clarify CNN’s headline was correct, the guy said that, but the content they reposted was false)
Imagine thinking this is proof of anything. “If a company’s revenue is 8.4b how could giving them an extra 6b improve it???”
Again, its not about improving it. Its about solving it.
Do you understand the difference between solve and improve?
“Solve” is an ill-defined metric.
It every person but one is perfectly taken care of, and that one is starving, is that insufficiently “solved”?
Is “solved” calories provided, or total guaranteed calories? Active daily value, sedentary, or minimal subsistence? Mean, median value? Is it over all ages, or age calibrated?
Does it include delivery, or just making locally available? What about security for areas that people will steal food for power and control?
Hinging it on “solved” is a way to guarantee you can never be held to it.
Well then maybe the world food guy shouldn’t have said SOLVE, and Elon have to call him out on his bullshit?
Whelp we can’t fix it permanently so those 42 million can just die.
Well then, maybe the food guy shouldn’t have claimed 6 billion could solve it then back track.
Words matter
Edit: and his lies made CNN news.
I think 42 million matter more than the pedantic argument of “solved” vs “making a massive impact” but you do you.
Its the world food guy who used the term first, not me or Elon.