No it didn’t… A smartphone is only a convenient way to access a variety of media and services in situations where using a desktop PC isn’t feasible or financially possible.
Some people use their phone for everything because that’s all they can afford. But the experience of entertainment is much better with a real TV, desktop computer, and audio system. So is doing actual work. A mouse and keyboard is infinitely better than a touch screen.
And only an idiot would replace all their high quality CDs with a Shitify subscription.
Also I wish we’d kept the old-school 4:3 aspect ratio for the smartphone era, I get I sound like I’m getting old but fuck vertical video in 9:16 so much. I can’t convince people to rotate their phones 90 degrees before pressing record, but if we’re going to tolerate cack-handed vertical nonsense at least 3:4 wastes less of the screen.
And basically none of that media/ data is actually stored on the phone. It is streamed to the phone from server farms/ data centers.
Write an essay/book on your phone for maximal back pain.
To be fair, just about any bluetooth keyboard will work with a phone!
Which means that neither the keyboard nor the screens in this picture were fully replaced by smartphones
Try to use a keyboard without a monitor or power. You can’t? Well, that means that keyboards haven’t fully replaced typewriters.
the wavebird was hardly replaced with the smartphone
The followup comment is stupid. Not even the keyboard was replaced…
Most folks dropped the home PC once phones were capable enough. Had a solid side-hustle fixing PCs 15-years ago. No chance of making a go at that now.
This had soul
Where is the jug of piss?
Everything but the phone, really
Ive never even seen this, let alone wanted it. I had something like this, but it was repurposed.
Nah, a phone can never replace a nice desk to work and play at, the maximum it can replace is the PC itself for productivity tasks if you hook it up to an USB hub and add actually longer term useable input and output devices like a screen that isnt tiny, a full-size keyboard and mouse, and good audio (I love 2.1 systems for this)
A phone is something to look at while taking a dump. A PC is for work, school, shopping, managing finances, basically everything except social media dilly dallying.
I use my phone extensively for reading - mainly the SCP wiki at the moment, currently at SCP-5959 - and for music. I also use it for most of my payments, although that is more of a convenience thing (i love that i do not need to take my wallet everywhere). Outside of that, it’s only a comms device.
Social media dilly dallying is almost all I do on my PC. I cannot image browsing lemmy on a tiny screen, let alone typing a comment.
Seems everyone on here references the various lemmy apps and I hardly see anyone saying they use a PC.
Hey now I don’t use the Lemmy app, I find the in browser site perfectly acceptable. Mind you I’m using firefox on a rather big phone but still. I lurk on space battles, but that’s moreso me reading fanfic so yeah.
I used to use a PSP for everything my phone does now back when I was 8 so do with that what you will, only difference is I’m not dumping a hundred ours into Persona 3 Portable.
I use Lemmy apps when I’m on my phone, and the web frontend when I’m on a laptop or desktop. The variety of apps have a lot more to discuss than web frontends (alexandrite is great) so I assumed that’s why there’s more banter about apps.
For people who work at a computer yes.
The vast vast majority of people were and are consumers. Most of the people who had this in their house sit on the couch with an iPad or their phone.
This desk wasn’t nice at all though.
Not to mention, all of the crap on it meant not actually being able to use the desk for anything other than computer work due to lack of space.
I mean, it’s a computer desk.
That was in response to the top-level comment saying that a phone can’t replace having a “nice desk to work and play at”, I was just pointing out that with the tech in place, you still don’t really have that.
You beat me to it! Exactly: No matter how hard you try, you just can’t balance a monitor and a keyboard/mouse on a phone (yet).
I think you can remove the “yet” from that statement. Touchscreen monitors exist, but most people don’t use them. A mouse is superior to a touchscreen, we just use a touchscreen on a phone because it’s a bit much to carry around a mouse in your pocket. A Keyboard with actual buttons is a superior interface to a touchscreen virtual keyboard. A bigger screen is better than a smaller screen, but you settle for a smaller screen on a phone so it will fit in your pocket.
I could see having some kind of docking station that plugs your phone into your monitor, keyboard and mouse setup so you could use it as a workstation. But that’s not fundamentally different from the set up in the photo.
Replaced? Everything on the picture is worse on the phone. So if you define replacement as embrace, extend and enshitify, then yeah sure
I’d call the landline and CDs exceptions. I can talk on the phone anywhere and play music anywhere with a BT speaker.
I still use a PC where most people use a phone, but it’s a tiny NUC vs. the monstrosities of the past.
Bingo
I still use my oak corner computer deck - just without the shelves in top.
I just like the layout, and I don’t like buying furniture!
I also call the oaken L home to this very day, though the lignum be a lie I cherish my plywood palladium.
It didn’t though. I see a nice 2.1 audio system with subwoofer, I see ownership of your favourite media, I see gamepads and nice gaming systems.
The phone just provides the illusion of ownership and gaming inputs that hurt your hands, with tin can audio (no matter how many balls they squeeze in those speakers).
That place is cozy, works on its own and can be healthy. A standard phone is designed around the attention economy and to milk you of money and attention, usually dependent on some company. A proper phone that works for you might exist (e.g. Murena, Volla, Nitrokey etc.), but actually owning stuff through it is still hard and ergonomic is shit without addons.
My phone and bittorrent DID replace ownership of my favorite media, at least for a while.
I was gonna say, phone + old laptop running a jellyfin server
Yep! Hence my ‘for a little while’ qualifier.
Hardware-wise, if you’re willing to put up with a tiny screen or somehow attach it to a larger screen, all of this was replaced.
I think that’s the main point OOP was making. But, yeah, they also didn’t think about your valid points.
Remember when the internet was relegated to a specific room in the house, and not in your pocket, making you sad all the time? Good times
Its really really really hard to explain this to the youngins today. Like you had to make time and a conscious effort to visit the Internet, so you generally did it with a specific purpose.
Maybe you’d get distracted and end up on rotten.com or a Buffy The Vampire Slayer fan chat room, but mostly you did your thing and then left the internet.
It’d be so much easier to curb my internet addiction if everyone else could stop being glued to it too. I would get bad FOMO if I tried to go fully analog
NTM how much of my professional life depends on apps
I acknowledge that for many people, the phone meets most of their needs for personal computer tasks. But I will never understand it. In my mind, the phone is mostly for mindless consumption. The minute I need to get some real work done, I need a monitor, keyboard and mouse. I have friends who handle bookings, online shopping and banking from their phone only. I can do some light managing, but I quickly feel like I’m losing my overview and it’s like having my hands and feet tight up while being held under water. And don’t get me started on watching movies on the phone. I would rather stare into the wall for 2 hours.
ALL that. Unless it absolutely cannot wait, I’ll hold up until I get home and have a full PC and 40" TV/monitor to look at.
Social media on a phone sounds like torture. Do y’all just have to read slow? Is that why there are so many of the same people making comments on here, because we have PCs and it’s not painful?
My wife is like you say. I gave her a nice Macbook and a nice Dell laptop I had from work. She uses her phone. And yes, even booked tickets last week.
David Lynch agreed (30s interview clip)
if all you did was jerk off and talk to your school buddies, yeah, sure, the phone replaced all of it
That’s all I did in the late 90’s, and that’s all I do now.
What else is there?
Yeah, man. I was a teenager!
Yup, replaced 100%




















