This is so strongly US-coded! I have only ever been yelled at in US, outside of it security agents are between nice and apathetic, not shouting around their power trips
TSA is security theater. It doesn’t matter if you are doing it “right” - they need to put on a show to make it look like security is happening. If they yell at you, know that you are NOT the target audience - the other people in line are. If there were actual rules and people were following them, they would have nobody to yell at, and there would be no performance.
Futurama said it well - if you do things right, people aren’t sure you’ve done anything at all.
TSA, in its current form, is a massive waste of time and taxpayer dollars.
As a European often flying in the US, standards vary wildly between airports over there. Some require me to take my laptops out of my backpack, others don’t care. And very often TSA want me to take my shoes off so they can huff my 16 hour buildup of feet sweat (and xray my shoes, but we all know that’s just an excuse). Is this because of differences in hardware capabilities, or do each state have their own rules?
Hardware and training are a big one. In Schipol/AMS they used to have the out-EU lines with some machines and some rules and the in-EU lines with other rules. Then they updated the machinery and now you leave everything in the bag all the time
Just flew home yesterday. I fly for work and have lots of electronics and batteries and the like in my carry-on.
I reach the scanner and ask the lady if electronics need to come out. She says yes.
I empty my pockets and place my backpack into a bin. I grab another bin, and begin unzipping my suitcase to remove all the electronics. When I go to place the (first) laptop in the bin, however, the lady was taking it away.
She said, “You don’t need this, do you?” I say yes. “For your suitcase?” I say, for the electronics I’m taking out. She smirks at me and says, “You could have placed that in the other bin.” I say I don’t think everything will fit. Besides, I’m normally told to place those items separately anyways.
I place the laptop in the empty bin. I then pull out a second laptop, an iPad, a portable speaker, and two drill batteries.
Before I can place anything else into the bin with the laptop. “SIR, all electronics need to be in their own separate bin.”
The rules are made up. They are a facade to lead us to believe the complexity equals security.
I’d be like ‘fine, you do it!’ And hand them all my shit.
They’ll steal it. TSA steals SOO much
My favorite is when there are signs to do one thing and the TSA agent is breathlessly yelling at everyone to do the opposite thing that the sign says.
“Don’t take your laptops out of your bags! Leave your electronics in your bags! Why is everyone taking their laptops out of their bags?!”
Uh, cause we can read?
… and the TSA can’t.
I think they draw from a hat daily. Or it’s like a madlibs they do before each shift. “Today we’re going to allow… ‘shoes’! lol we’re doing shoes guys!”
Every single time I’m on the lookout for a sign and listening for an employee outlining what I need to know, and there’s nothing. Then I get to the front and they are angry at people “Sir, you never have to take off your shoes! Go through the metal detector, like always!”
Of course, in the other airport on the way back it’s an exasperated “Sir, you always have to take off your shoes! Go through the scanner, not the metal detector! You should know this!”
Supposedly the ‘randomness’ makes it harder to plan an attack. But it’s all just security theater anyway. TSA is a waste of taxpayer dollars
Indeed, an attack ain’t so hard to plan. Why blow up a plane? A suicide bomber just needs a large gathering of people packed together to get a large body count and sow maximum terror. A plane is one way to do that, but an airport security checkpoint would be the perfect spot, too, and you can just walk up to one and get in line.
There are so many easy ways that a terrorist or saboteur could mess us up, and the fact that they just don’t tells us all we need to know about the actual terrorist threat and the usefulness of the TSA. (But my favorite example is all of the signage and checkpoints at train stations. I’ve never seen one of those checkpoints operating, but somebody must have thought it would make good theater at one time.)
United States Department of Homeland Security: The worlds most expensive symbolic gesture.
Even the Bush administration thought it was a total waste of money but John Bolton managed to whip enough of Congress into a frenzy to get it approved.
I have an analogy that applies here.
When I was a kid I would spend time with my mom and when a baby would cry in public (in church, for example) my mom would smile. At one point, I was like “why are you smiling when a baby is being loud?!” and my mom explained that babies are going to cry. You can either be upset about it or you can see it as something kind of joyful.
As I’ve gotten older I’ve used that a lot, in various situations.
I don’t fly as much as I used to so I don’t deal with silly TSA agents as much. But over time I trained myself to be filled with joy any time I heard a TSA agent become annoyed. Seriously, what a blessing! One of the least valuable members of society genuinely hates their job.
I get to be done with this in minutes, then I’m off to whatever I’m doing. The anger shows that they hate the purgatory they’re stuck in, and to me that’s awesome.
I’m sorry, do you have to pat me down because of your stupid rules? Why do I look less annoyed than you?
It’s joyful when babies cry.
I haven’t traveled in a few months, but seatac had some genuinely fun tsa agents. It was a nice way to fly out. Coming back was a different story.
I live in Philly. The TSA agents here are incredibly rude douchebags, which is to say they fit in perfectly with the passengers.
A part of me wonders if the point is to keep everyone on their toes, to keep the entire process less predictable. Like if you are trying to sneak something through and there is a well known standard procedure, then you can plan around it and find a way to circumvent it. But if it changes every other time you go through it, then you don’t know what to expect and can’t make a plan accordingly, making your chances of success that much harder. And it may even make you more likely to give yourself away for your nervousness.
But we all know it isn’t operating at that sort of level of competence.
Always go in clueless. They don’t like to see anyone who knows what’s going on. It’s not just a different month or day, I’ve seen two lines doing different things. If I thought they were doing actual security, I’d say they mix it up on purpose so no one can find a method that always gets by them.
The last time I was through they just ran a whole line of people through the metal detector at once. So if we can do that once, why can’t we just do that normally? Either the big expensive scanner was not working that day, or the person who knew how to run it was off.
they mix it up on purpose so no one can find a method that always gets by them.
But that’s not the threat model! A terrorist only needs to get through once and blow up the plane. The security has to work every single time. Hell, a terrorist getting caught at security will also frighten people, so they don’t even have to succeed to be effective.
Worse, it is different depending on which airport you’re at. Last time I traveled I had to keep electronics in the bag and shoes on going to my destination, but remove all electronics and my shoes for the return flight. Fortunately the signage was pretty clear where I was, but I still got stuck behind people that somehow missed those.
how is that worse than the same airport, possibly same checkpoint, doing things different depending on day or even shift/agent?
Because you typically only pass through the security of each airport once per trip?
I guess I read the OP as “when I was here last time, the rules were this; but now the rules are different and I got yelled for just doing what I was told to do last time” and wanted to add that it’s not even consistent between airports. I guess I haven’t traveled enough to have experience a difference between agents or shifts. I would have to agree: that level of inconsistency would be even worse.
Yeah that’s exactly what I got from OP: the place I goto changes policies. Different airports in different states or countries I’d expect differences and inconsistencies to an extent.
Some lady put some paper they stamped or whatever outside my passport and I walked through the end at SFO. Some other random lady working there was angry and took the paper and put it into my passport while going “oh come on, do it right!” I was like wtf? same thing to the Irish guy near me and then be was like, “she’s a bundle of sunshine isn’t she?” You’d have thought that she just flew the red eye flight, rather than us.
I see, this person did not go to a strict eastern european school. That shit was confusing as hell
SIR, NO TWEETING IN LINE
That’s perfect. I gotta rewatch that show, I don’t remember this sketch.
They just aired new skits.
I really though this was going to be Key and Peele. Still happy.
If you just do the maximum and fast no one will yell at you.
Or, TSA could kiss my ass
More likely they will finger it
I can never remember, when they do this am I allowed to bring 3oz or less of water-based lube or does it have to be oil-based?






