So my parents should have converted to Catholicism before abusing me, causing me lifelong mental (and probably physical) issues because that would apparently make it OK? They could’ve confessed and been fine and not had to face any consequences despite child abuse being ongoing? They’re just fine to let a child continuing to experience things with lifelong consequences?
So my parents should have converted to Catholicism before abusing me, causing me lifelong mental (and probably physical) issues because that would apparently make it OK?
I mean no? But if Catholic!your parents knew they’d get reported if they confessed they most likely just wouldn’t confess so it’s a wash anyway. To be clear though I think they should report this stuff, but there is a good faith argument for not doing so is my point.
I don’t get the good-faith argument. So if I start a religion and declare that confessions are a deeply-held, critical part of the religion, I suddenly have an argument to not report people doing terrible things?
If the people come confess stuff to you on the basis of this part of your religion, and you assure them that you won’t report whatever they say, yeah pretty much. The utilitarian logic is important here; nobody would report this stuff if there were consequences for doing so.
To me, that’s a religion that should not exist. They accept those people, their on-going abuse and poor treatment of others, etc. Get them out. Get them help. Don’t just say “well, say some stuff and try harder next time”. The existence of a religion that allows that is itself more-or-less criminal to me. Meanwhile, let’s pretend everything is fine and you go on hurting people/stealing/raping/whatever.
Presumably the issue is reporting stuff they learn in confessions, which I mean you can see where he’s coming from.
So my parents should have converted to Catholicism before abusing me, causing me lifelong mental (and probably physical) issues because that would apparently make it OK? They could’ve confessed and been fine and not had to face any consequences despite child abuse being ongoing? They’re just fine to let a child continuing to experience things with lifelong consequences?
I mean no? But if Catholic!your parents knew they’d get reported if they confessed they most likely just wouldn’t confess so it’s a wash anyway. To be clear though I think they should report this stuff, but there is a good faith argument for not doing so is my point.
I don’t get the good-faith argument. So if I start a religion and declare that confessions are a deeply-held, critical part of the religion, I suddenly have an argument to not report people doing terrible things?
If the people come confess stuff to you on the basis of this part of your religion, and you assure them that you won’t report whatever they say, yeah pretty much. The utilitarian logic is important here; nobody would report this stuff if there were consequences for doing so.
To me, that’s a religion that should not exist. They accept those people, their on-going abuse and poor treatment of others, etc. Get them out. Get them help. Don’t just say “well, say some stuff and try harder next time”. The existence of a religion that allows that is itself more-or-less criminal to me. Meanwhile, let’s pretend everything is fine and you go on hurting people/stealing/raping/whatever.