I’m not sure if people are truly this politically uninformed, or are just larping to sow discontent amongst the left.
AOC released a video and basically explained how/why Hakeem was going to be selected as Speaker - anyone who would vote against him would not get any committee appointments, effectively neutering their ability to shape legislation in this coming term.
The best chance for a change in leadership will come as part of the 2028 election; a successful primary challenge to unseat Hakeem would open the way for an open floor vote for a new Speaker.
I’m not sure if people are truly this politically uninformed, or are just larping to sow discontent amongst the left.
Paragraphs 2 and 3 don’t seem to naturally follow from the first. You started with “larping to sow discontent”, and then described completely dysfunctional behaviour for which discontent should absolutely be the correct response.
Speaker of the House is not an omnipotent position, and the progressive wing of the party can easily push back against ineffective leadership. Heck, the number of times Mike Johnson failed to pass legistlation during the current session should more than attest to that.
The best chance for a change in leadership will come as part of the 2028 election; a successful primary challenge to unseat Hakeem
just one more election bro we’re totally gonna get them this time bro and everything will be perfect there’s just one guy standing in the way of utopia bro trust me bro this time will be different
Rome wasn’t built in a day, and neither did the US arrive at its current predicament overnight.
It takes longer to build things up than it is to tear them down, and your solution is to what - sit on the sidelines while the opposition sets fire to everything you hold near and dear?
Secret vote is such a misleading term to use here. It was a preliminary vote in a closed door session of the Democratic caucus only, before it comes to a floor vote. The purpose of the closed door vote is for Democrats to get aligned as a party so the floor vote isn’t fucked up.
It’s not a secret. Nobody was trying to hide what was happening.
There’s plenty to be upset about but that ain’t it
AOC released a video and basically explained how/why Hakeem was going to be selected as Speaker - anyone who would vote against him would not get any committee appointments, effectively neutering their ability to shape legislation in this coming term.
And you buy that bullshit? Get enough people to vote against him, and you get a new speaker who will write the rules so no one is punished for voting against him. This is basically an admission that the House is being run by its own version of Trump - a strong man willing to abuse his power to retain his power. The fact that the Democratic party is willing to tolerate this level of cronyism in its upper most ranks really does show they’re beyond saving and that nothing is going to change.
But go ahead, listen to them and give them a pass. Two years from now they’ll have another excuse, just like they did two years before now, and two years before that.
Jeffries is a rotating villain. The real issue is the moneyed lobbied interests and the consultant class that brought us milquetoast centrist messaging for Kamala Harris. And the whole campaigning with Liz Cheney. That is what the establishment dems are trying to force feed us, “Mamdami got elected with his progressive agenda, but thats New York! That won’t work anywhere else.”
Then Abdul El-sayed won. Angie Nixon almost won Florida with like a literal $5000 given at the 11th hour from the democratic party. Talarico won Texas on a populist message.
Now they are attempting to rewrite reality by saying that the centrists did better than the progressives. Which is a bald faced lie and not taking into account the party attempting to sway the election in favor of non-progressive candidates by withholding money and support, supporting the other candidate etc.
The whole party is ran by fucking idiots who would rather attempt to court the mythical centrists than just simply run and pass bills that help the American people but goes against moneyed interest.
The whole party is ran by fucking idiots who would rather attempt to court the mythical centrists than just simply run and pass bills that help the American people but goes against moneyed interest.
While this statement is correct, you’re drawing the wrong conclusion - the solution is to unseat the corporatists and replace them with individuals dedicated to serving their constituents. Progress will literally take time, and it will be a (figurative) bloodbath to wrench power away from monied interests.
The reason so few stood to vote against Jeffries is because the numbers weren’t there - and there’s no point for any politician to neuter themselves ahead of what is going to be such a pivotal time in US politics.
Look, I’m not saying I believe AOC, but you’re arguing that ”things would be fine if everyone just voted right," which, not how things work. You ask me, her and Mamdani worked this out a year ago to keep him out of leaning on the mayoral. And I’m not necessarily against that calculus.
There simply isn’t enough support amongst the progressive wing of the Democrats to take Jeffries head-on and unseat him - there was no point in expending so much political capital on a futile endeavour.
But as long as the composition of Democratic representatives continues to trend more progressive every election - it is only a matter of time before they will have the numbers.
In the meantime, it’s up to the progressives currently elected to strategically hold their centrist/corporatist colleagues to task when they have leverage while not excessively ostracising themselves when they don’t.
The US has two swings at Schumer; first to elect CVH as Majority Leader in the Senate - and then to unseat him in the 2028 primary should he be foolish enough to try and run again.
Notably, AOC’s video tries to bring focus to the fact that he was running entirely unopposed, and mentions that she herself didn’t have any interest in running because she would have to dilute her own platform and objectives.
Wait so she basically said they were held hostage and forced to vote for this? Not really a great look for the democrats. But I guess the point is don’t hate on AOC etc for their vote? Sure it can not automatically be disqualifying but it’s surely a tick in the “bad look” category.
I’m not sure if people are truly this politically uninformed, or are just larping to sow discontent amongst the left.
AOC released a video and basically explained how/why Hakeem was going to be selected as Speaker - anyone who would vote against him would not get any committee appointments, effectively neutering their ability to shape legislation in this coming term.
The best chance for a change in leadership will come as part of the 2028 election; a successful primary challenge to unseat Hakeem would open the way for an open floor vote for a new Speaker.
Paragraphs 2 and 3 don’t seem to naturally follow from the first. You started with “larping to sow discontent”, and then described completely dysfunctional behaviour for which discontent should absolutely be the correct response.
He’s a bully. And too many are letting him continue.
Speaker of the House is not an omnipotent position, and the progressive wing of the party can easily push back against ineffective leadership. Heck, the number of times Mike Johnson failed to pass legistlation during the current session should more than attest to that.
just one more election bro we’re totally gonna get them this time bro and everything will be perfect there’s just one guy standing in the way of utopia bro trust me bro this time will be different
Rome wasn’t built in a day, and neither did the US arrive at its current predicament overnight.
It takes longer to build things up than it is to tear them down, and your solution is to what - sit on the sidelines while the opposition sets fire to everything you hold near and dear?
It’s never going to be utopia. Just pushing the boulder uphill day after day. That’s them breaks.
But that’s no excuse to give up.
“secret vote”
Unless you vote against the predetermined outcome. Then they will FIND YOU.
I had very low expectations of the democratic majority. I didn’t expect it to be fewer than 3 weeks before they:
It’s still better than the Republicans winning, but my slightly rekindled hope is nice and thoroughly extinguished. See you all in hell.
Secret vote is such a misleading term to use here. It was a preliminary vote in a closed door session of the Democratic caucus only, before it comes to a floor vote. The purpose of the closed door vote is for Democrats to get aligned as a party so the floor vote isn’t fucked up.
It’s not a secret. Nobody was trying to hide what was happening.
There’s plenty to be upset about but that ain’t it
And you buy that bullshit? Get enough people to vote against him, and you get a new speaker who will write the rules so no one is punished for voting against him. This is basically an admission that the House is being run by its own version of Trump - a strong man willing to abuse his power to retain his power. The fact that the Democratic party is willing to tolerate this level of cronyism in its upper most ranks really does show they’re beyond saving and that nothing is going to change.
But go ahead, listen to them and give them a pass. Two years from now they’ll have another excuse, just like they did two years before now, and two years before that.
You act like 90% of Democrats aren’t just establishment pro-ICE morons like Jon Ossoff
Jeffries is a rotating villain. The real issue is the moneyed lobbied interests and the consultant class that brought us milquetoast centrist messaging for Kamala Harris. And the whole campaigning with Liz Cheney. That is what the establishment dems are trying to force feed us, “Mamdami got elected with his progressive agenda, but thats New York! That won’t work anywhere else.”
Then Abdul El-sayed won. Angie Nixon almost won Florida with like a literal $5000 given at the 11th hour from the democratic party. Talarico won Texas on a populist message.
Now they are attempting to rewrite reality by saying that the centrists did better than the progressives. Which is a bald faced lie and not taking into account the party attempting to sway the election in favor of non-progressive candidates by withholding money and support, supporting the other candidate etc.
The whole party is ran by fucking idiots who would rather attempt to court the mythical centrists than just simply run and pass bills that help the American people but goes against moneyed interest.
While this statement is correct, you’re drawing the wrong conclusion - the solution is to unseat the corporatists and replace them with individuals dedicated to serving their constituents. Progress will literally take time, and it will be a (figurative) bloodbath to wrench power away from monied interests.
The reason so few stood to vote against Jeffries is because the numbers weren’t there - and there’s no point for any politician to neuter themselves ahead of what is going to be such a pivotal time in US politics.
Look, I’m not saying I believe AOC, but you’re arguing that ”things would be fine if everyone just voted right," which, not how things work. You ask me, her and Mamdani worked this out a year ago to keep him out of leaning on the mayoral. And I’m not necessarily against that calculus.
Yes, I accept objective reality.
There simply isn’t enough support amongst the progressive wing of the Democrats to take Jeffries head-on and unseat him - there was no point in expending so much political capital on a futile endeavour.
But as long as the composition of Democratic representatives continues to trend more progressive every election - it is only a matter of time before they will have the numbers.
In the meantime, it’s up to the progressives currently elected to strategically hold their centrist/corporatist colleagues to task when they have leverage while not excessively ostracising themselves when they don’t.
This.
Jeffries is manipulable, and it was hard to rule out inevitability with this one.
It’s Schumer who we have the most leverage against, and is arguably a more important race. If we lose that one, THEN we let the anguish sink in.
Call your fucking Senator to support Van Hollen.
The US has two swings at Schumer; first to elect CVH as Majority Leader in the Senate - and then to unseat him in the 2028 primary should he be foolish enough to try and run again.
Notably, AOC’s video tries to bring focus to the fact that he was running entirely unopposed, and mentions that she herself didn’t have any interest in running because she would have to dilute her own platform and objectives.
Wait so she basically said they were held hostage and forced to vote for this? Not really a great look for the democrats. But I guess the point is don’t hate on AOC etc for their vote? Sure it can not automatically be disqualifying but it’s surely a tick in the “bad look” category.