My early trans experiences weren’t traumatic, and it’s not like I magically remember these things better in retrospect because I decided I was trans later in life. I also have lots of memories of other things from that time in my life. I’m just constantly baffled by adults who act like they sprang fully formed from the head of Zeus yesterday and were never kids.
Anyway this is a weird hill to die on. Are you okay?
What? I don’t think this is even a hill, never mind one I’m dying on. I didn’t suggest your memories are traumatic, just more memorable than the corresponding ones a non trans person might have had.
You remember wishing you’d wake up a girl. If you’d been a boy in a boy’s body, do you think you’d ever have wished you’d wake up a boy? Of course not, it doesn’t make sense to wish for something you already have! So no boy who isn’t trans would even have had a similar experience to that particular one.
Pick any way in which people vary as children. Someone who is an outlier will have lots of experiences of being different that they remember. Someone who is close to the average will have lots of experiences of being just like their peers that are completely unremarkable and so swiftly forgotten.
I don’t think I’m saying anything especially controversial here… it was just supposed to be a perspective you may not have considered, not an assertion that you’re wrong.
I think you’re drastically misunderstanding the issue. You’re treating this like there’s something special about being trans that doesn’t apply to the analogous non-trans stuff any other kid would have experienced. Just take the trans aspect completely out of this and look at what I’m actually saying: Adults make assumptions about children that they could only make if they do not remember their own childhoods. That’s it. That’s the message. Have a nice day and goodbye.
My early trans experiences weren’t traumatic, and it’s not like I magically remember these things better in retrospect because I decided I was trans later in life. I also have lots of memories of other things from that time in my life. I’m just constantly baffled by adults who act like they sprang fully formed from the head of Zeus yesterday and were never kids.
Anyway this is a weird hill to die on. Are you okay?
What? I don’t think this is even a hill, never mind one I’m dying on. I didn’t suggest your memories are traumatic, just more memorable than the corresponding ones a non trans person might have had.
You remember wishing you’d wake up a girl. If you’d been a boy in a boy’s body, do you think you’d ever have wished you’d wake up a boy? Of course not, it doesn’t make sense to wish for something you already have! So no boy who isn’t trans would even have had a similar experience to that particular one.
Pick any way in which people vary as children. Someone who is an outlier will have lots of experiences of being different that they remember. Someone who is close to the average will have lots of experiences of being just like their peers that are completely unremarkable and so swiftly forgotten.
I don’t think I’m saying anything especially controversial here… it was just supposed to be a perspective you may not have considered, not an assertion that you’re wrong.
I think you’re drastically misunderstanding the issue. You’re treating this like there’s something special about being trans that doesn’t apply to the analogous non-trans stuff any other kid would have experienced. Just take the trans aspect completely out of this and look at what I’m actually saying: Adults make assumptions about children that they could only make if they do not remember their own childhoods. That’s it. That’s the message. Have a nice day and goodbye.
Yeah I’m just offering an explanation of why an adult may not remember their childhood (in one particular way). See ya