A way I’ve begun to think about it, is that rights are by definition universal to all people.
For you to have rights, it must be universally applied or else it’s not a human right.
So there’s no such thing as “rights for me and not for thee”, by the very nature of rights it’s either everyone has them or no one has them.
So for example, you cannot expect the right for women’s safety if you tolerate black women being unsafe, you cannot expect the right to bodily autonomy if you tolerate trans women being banned from gender affirming care.
It’s not an issue of who gets rights, it’s an issue of whether those rights exist or not. The idea that there’s some middle ground is just propaganda by those who don’t want these rights to exist.
Human rights, I would agree. But different countries offer different rights to their citizens vs non-citizens, and that’s fine. Like, in the US, I have a right to vote, but a non-citizen doesn’t. We both have a right to free speech, though, because that’s considered a human right by the American government (supposedly).
Where it gets a little more tricky is rights based on ethnicity. A Native American has additional rights that I don’t regarding access to services and support available to them. I’m fine with that, but I understand where someone who isn’t is coming from, even though I disagree with them. Does that make sense? Maybe you could call these entitlements instead? Maybe they already are and I’m just ignorant?
At this point I would argue that non-citizens should be afforded rights as well, otherwise it becomes to easy for an authoritarian state to simply redefine who a citizen is.
At least the US cannot be so trusted. There is already an effort by the regime to cut into birthright citizenship, and to broaden circumstances by which someone can be denaturalized.
Suspected non-citizens are being denied habeas corpus, and due process, and as a result, over five-hundred US citizens are known to be in the ICE concentration camp system, or deported to a country where they don’t have citizenship or rights.
I’d argue any place that can be radicalized towards white supremacy risks authoritarianist pushes to strip away citizenship from undesirable groups, to justify stripping them of even basic human rights.
This is the One Ring. You assure everyone rights, including groups you find reprehensible, or you leave an opening to deny anyone rights.
Or to borrow from another milieu, don’t set a dangerous precedent that Magneto might turn against humans or to advantage the Brotherhood of Mutants. Because he will.
but why should we even have the concept of citizenship? If you’re here you’re here, how you got here and your reason for being here doesn’t matter, you’re still a person.
Nah, non-citizens need to have those rights too; otherwise the rights can be taken away if you’re not a citizen. In an ideal world, people would have a say in everything that affects them that is proportional to how much it affects them. If there is an organization that mainly serves the interests of one region, but has a huge affect on other regions as well, then those other regions should get a say in what that organization does.
Coming back to our current system, voting should be based on if you live here long term and nothing else. A natural born citizen who leaves and lives full time in another country doesn’t get a vote, nor should some rich person who lives elsewhere and visits for a couple weeks during election season. Similarly, a non-citizen who lives here permanently with no signs that they will leave should get to vote (as well as all the benefits of the taxes that they still have to pay). Really, they should get their citizenship far sooner than they do; our current application process is specifically designed to keep brown immigrants as second class citizens with the threat of deportation keeping them in line.
When it comes to Native Americans Reservations, they are not given more rights based on “ethnicity”; they are citizens of separate nations that were enveloped by an expansionary, genocidal nation that took over most of their actual homelands. To a large extent, those nations are legally separate countries, even if the practicality of it means that they cannot be independent from America. As their lives are intrinsically influenced by the federal government and the states that surround them, they still get a say in those governments.
Like I said earlier, we should get a say in every organization that majorly influences us; the current legal reality is merely an inadequate compromise. We should really have a democratic say in how any businesses we work at is run as well, not simply as unions that need to be fought for tooth and nail, but as a basic standard that every corporation must abide by. Even co-ops should be influenced by the people and communities that their work impacts. That’s how society needs to actually work to not devolve into oligarchy and imperialism.
I think I would consider the Native American ones closer to reparations, though woefully inadequate, for hunting them like animals, stealing their land and starving them in the wastelands, stealing abusing and killing their children in an effort to wipe out their entire culture, and desecrating their most sacred spaces.
This is where the distinction between inalienable/human rights and citizens rights should be highlighted.
Just because you don’t have the right to vote somewhere you’re living does not mean you don’t (or I guess now it’s shouldn’t) have the right to not be kidnapped by masked thugs and imprisoned indefinitely.
I could agree that anyone with an address in the country should be allowed to vote, but I don’t know that someone visiting for two weeks when elections happen should be voting.
I did note it to myself but I also figured it may be good to lay out how such a system could work and addresses seems a practical method so I thought it worth sharing. I could also see a potential argument that even if you are visiting a country the government of that country is still governing you personally while you are there, therefore it is “your government” while there. Pedantic? Yes. Something someone could argue? This is the internet, so also yes.
A way I’ve begun to think about it, is that rights are by definition universal to all people.
For you to have rights, it must be universally applied or else it’s not a human right.
So there’s no such thing as “rights for me and not for thee”, by the very nature of rights it’s either everyone has them or no one has them.
So for example, you cannot expect the right for women’s safety if you tolerate black women being unsafe, you cannot expect the right to bodily autonomy if you tolerate trans women being banned from gender affirming care.
It’s not an issue of who gets rights, it’s an issue of whether those rights exist or not. The idea that there’s some middle ground is just propaganda by those who don’t want these rights to exist.
Also rights should not depend on the party on power, else they are just privileges
Human rights, I would agree. But different countries offer different rights to their citizens vs non-citizens, and that’s fine. Like, in the US, I have a right to vote, but a non-citizen doesn’t. We both have a right to free speech, though, because that’s considered a human right by the American government (supposedly).
Where it gets a little more tricky is rights based on ethnicity. A Native American has additional rights that I don’t regarding access to services and support available to them. I’m fine with that, but I understand where someone who isn’t is coming from, even though I disagree with them. Does that make sense? Maybe you could call these entitlements instead? Maybe they already are and I’m just ignorant?
At this point I would argue that non-citizens should be afforded rights as well, otherwise it becomes to easy for an authoritarian state to simply redefine who a citizen is.
At least the US cannot be so trusted. There is already an effort by the regime to cut into birthright citizenship, and to broaden circumstances by which someone can be denaturalized.
Suspected non-citizens are being denied habeas corpus, and due process, and as a result, over five-hundred US citizens are known to be in the ICE concentration camp system, or deported to a country where they don’t have citizenship or rights.
I’d argue any place that can be radicalized towards white supremacy risks authoritarianist pushes to strip away citizenship from undesirable groups, to justify stripping them of even basic human rights.
This is the One Ring. You assure everyone rights, including groups you find reprehensible, or you leave an opening to deny anyone rights.
Or to borrow from another milieu, don’t set a dangerous precedent that Magneto might turn against humans or to advantage the Brotherhood of Mutants. Because he will.
but why should we even have the concept of citizenship? If you’re here you’re here, how you got here and your reason for being here doesn’t matter, you’re still a person.
Nah, non-citizens need to have those rights too; otherwise the rights can be taken away if you’re not a citizen. In an ideal world, people would have a say in everything that affects them that is proportional to how much it affects them. If there is an organization that mainly serves the interests of one region, but has a huge affect on other regions as well, then those other regions should get a say in what that organization does.
Coming back to our current system, voting should be based on if you live here long term and nothing else. A natural born citizen who leaves and lives full time in another country doesn’t get a vote, nor should some rich person who lives elsewhere and visits for a couple weeks during election season. Similarly, a non-citizen who lives here permanently with no signs that they will leave should get to vote (as well as all the benefits of the taxes that they still have to pay). Really, they should get their citizenship far sooner than they do; our current application process is specifically designed to keep brown immigrants as second class citizens with the threat of deportation keeping them in line.
When it comes to Native Americans Reservations, they are not given more rights based on “ethnicity”; they are citizens of separate nations that were enveloped by an expansionary, genocidal nation that took over most of their actual homelands. To a large extent, those nations are legally separate countries, even if the practicality of it means that they cannot be independent from America. As their lives are intrinsically influenced by the federal government and the states that surround them, they still get a say in those governments.
Like I said earlier, we should get a say in every organization that majorly influences us; the current legal reality is merely an inadequate compromise. We should really have a democratic say in how any businesses we work at is run as well, not simply as unions that need to be fought for tooth and nail, but as a basic standard that every corporation must abide by. Even co-ops should be influenced by the people and communities that their work impacts. That’s how society needs to actually work to not devolve into oligarchy and imperialism.
I think I would consider the Native American ones closer to reparations, though woefully inadequate, for hunting them like animals, stealing their land and starving them in the wastelands, stealing abusing and killing their children in an effort to wipe out their entire culture, and desecrating their most sacred spaces.
Yes, I completely agree.
This is where the distinction between inalienable/human rights and citizens rights should be highlighted.
Just because you don’t have the right to vote somewhere you’re living does not mean you don’t (or I guess now it’s shouldn’t) have the right to not be kidnapped by masked thugs and imprisoned indefinitely.
Personally I think that “having a say in how your government works” is a human right.
Yes, that means I support noncitizens being able to vote.
I’d be all for letting other countries vote in US elections at this rate
I could agree that anyone with an address in the country should be allowed to vote, but I don’t know that someone visiting for two weeks when elections happen should be voting.
Note that I said people should have a say in how their government functions. That wouldn’t apply to visitors but would apply to residents
I did note it to myself but I also figured it may be good to lay out how such a system could work and addresses seems a practical method so I thought it worth sharing. I could also see a potential argument that even if you are visiting a country the government of that country is still governing you personally while you are there, therefore it is “your government” while there. Pedantic? Yes. Something someone could argue? This is the internet, so also yes.
Gotcha!
And honestly I kinda agree that if you’re visiting you should have some say - but that say is primarily your ability to leave
John Locke would be proud.